Skip to content

How to Choose a Postpartum Therapist: What to Look For and 10 Questions to Ask

September 11, 2025•18 min read•Postpartum Mental Health
Watercolor of an empty armchair in a soft pink room

Finding a therapist when you are already running on no sleep feels like one more job you did not sign up for. Every profile says "women's issues" or "anxiety and depression." Half of them mention postpartum somewhere in a long list. You cannot tell who actually knows this work, and you do not have the energy to interview six strangers to find out.

I am a perinatal psychologist in Austin, and I am often the person a mom calls after the first therapist did not work out. So this is what I would tell a friend: what a postpartum specialist actually is, where to find one, the ten questions that sort specialists from generalists in a single 15-minute call, and the red flags that mean keep looking.

What a perinatal mental health therapist actually is

"Perinatal" covers pregnancy through the first year after birth. In practice it also covers trying to conceive, loss, and the birth itself, because mental health problems can start at any point along that road.

A perinatal specialist is a licensed therapist or psychologist who has trained specifically in this period. The most recognizable marker is the PMH-C, the Perinatal Mental Health Certification from Postpartum Support International, which requires dedicated training and an exam. The certification is not the only way to be good at this, but it tells you someone chose to specialize.

What that training changes in the room:

  • They know that scary, intrusive thoughts about the baby are common, and they do not panic when you describe one. This matters more than anything else on this list.
  • They understand what sleep deprivation, feeding struggles, and hormonal shifts do to mood, and they factor those in instead of treating you like any other adult with depression.
  • They give you things to try that fit a life with a newborn, not homework that assumes a quiet hour and a notebook.
  • They know which prescribers understand pregnancy and breastfeeding, and when it is time to loop one in.
  • They ask about your birth, your feeding, your sleep, and your support, because those are usually where the story is.

A general therapist can be excellent. The risk is that they treat postpartum depression like any depression, or that they hear "I had a thought about dropping her" and get nervous, instead of telling you that is a very normal thought after a baby. If you have had that experience, the problem was the fit.

Where to look

  • Postpartum Support International's directory at postpartum.net. Filter by your state, and look for PMH-C after the name.
  • Psychology Today. Under "Issues," filter for postpartum or pregnancy, then read the bio. You are looking for specific perinatal training, not a mention in a list of twenty things.
  • The people who already see you. Your OB, midwife, pediatrician, or lactation consultant knows who they refer to and who their patients come back and thank them for. Ask them.
  • Video widens the pool. Psychologists with PSYPACT authority can see you by video in more than forty states, so you are not limited to who has an office within twenty minutes. Online therapy works well for postpartum depression and anxiety, and it means you never have to leave the baby or plan for traffic.

Make a list of three. Most specialists offer a free 15-minute call, and three calls is enough to feel the difference.

The 10 questions to ask on the consult call

You do not need to ask all ten. Pick the ones that matter most to you, and listen as much for how they answer as for what they say.

1. What portion of your practice is pregnant or postpartum moms?

You want "most" or "all." "I've worked with some new moms" means you would be the exception in their week.

2. What training do you have specifically in perinatal mental health?

PMH-C, or specific coursework and supervision in this area. "I have kids myself" is a life experience, not training.

3. How do you work with postpartum anxiety and intrusive thoughts?

The answer you want is calm. Something like: those thoughts are common, they are not a sign you will act on them, and here is how we treat them. If they seem alarmed, or start talking about hospitalization because of a thought alone, keep looking. Here is what those thoughts can mean, so you know what a good answer sounds like.

4. What would our first month look like?

You want a plan. A real answer names an approach, such as CBT or interpersonal therapy, says how often you would meet at first, and describes what you would actually do between sessions. In my practice that is weekly for the first eight to twelve weeks, with small things to try that fit around a baby, then tapering sessions as my moms start to feel better.

5. How will I know it is working, and what happens if it is not?

A good therapist checks in on this out loud and changes course when the first approach is not landing. I tell people honestly that most moms feel more like themselves around the third month. If someone promises faster, or will not give you any timeline at all, notice that.

6. Do you work with prescribers, and what is your view on medication?

You want someone neutral and collaborative. "You definitely need medication" is not their call. "I don't believe in medicating new moms" is a reason to leave. The right answer is that it depends on you, and they know who to send you to if it would help.

7. Can I bring my baby, and can we meet by video?

Yes and yes. A specialist expects a baby in the room sometimes and a nap-time video session other times. Babies are in my office every week, and I look forward to it.

8. How soon can I start?

Two or three weeks is normal for someone good. More than a month, ask whether they can refer you to a colleague with openings. Waiting six weeks when you are struggling now is too long.

9. What does it cost, are you in network, and do you provide superbills?

Many perinatal specialists are out of network. That is not a reason to rule someone out, but you want clear answers. I wrote separately about what therapy costs in Austin, whether insurance covers postpartum therapy, and how superbills get you reimbursed.

10. What happens if I am having a bad week between sessions?

You want a plain answer about how to reach them, how fast they respond, and what to do in an emergency. Vagueness here is a warning sign.

Red flags, in one place

  • "All new moms feel this way."
  • Generic advice on the first call: sleep when the baby sleeps, try yoga, practice gratitude.
  • Visible alarm at an intrusive thought.
  • A bio that lists fifteen specialties with postpartum somewhere in the middle.
  • No plan after three sessions.
  • Comments on your feeding or sleep choices.
  • You leave sessions feeling worse about yourself as a mom.

Any one of these is enough to try someone else. You are allowed to switch.

Video or in person

Both work. The research on video therapy for postpartum depression and anxiety is reassuring, and the practical case is obvious: no childcare, no commute, and you can feed the baby mid-session. In person gives you a room that is not your house and an hour that belongs only to you, which some moms need more than they expect. Many specialists offer both, and the best setup is often in person when you can and video when you cannot.

What the first sessions should look like

The first session is mostly listening. A specialist will ask about your symptoms and how long they have been there, your pregnancy and birth, feeding, sleep, what support you actually have, and your history. By the second or third session you should have a clear picture of what is going on and a plan for what you will work on. If you have never been to therapy, I wrote a walk-through of the first session so there are no surprises.

If you are in Austin and want to talk to me

I am a Psy.D., a licensed psychologist since 2013, and a PMH-C, and perinatal work is what I do. I work mostly from interpersonal therapy, which was built for exactly the role changes and relationship strain that come with a new baby, and I use CBT for the practical side: calming your body and taking the power out of anxious thoughts. For intrusive thoughts specifically I use ERP and I-CBT, two forms of CBT built for exactly those thoughts and the doubt that drives them. I also do psychodynamic work, because becoming a mom has a way of bringing old things back up: how you were mothered, losses you thought you had put away, patterns you did not know you were repeating. Understanding where your patterns come from is how you get to choose new ones. I see moms in person at my office on Balcones Drive, centrally located off MoPac and 2222, and by video across most of the country. Babies are welcome in both. The first conversation is a free 15-minute call, and you are welcome to ask me these exact questions on it. If I am not the right fit, I will tell you, and I will point you to someone who is.

Book a free 15-minute call

Trust your gut

Credentials get someone onto your list. Whether you can be honest with them is what keeps them there. After the call, ask yourself: did I feel heard, did their answers sound like they have done this many times, and can I imagine telling this person the thing I have not told anyone? If the answer is yes, book the first session. If it is no, call the next name. The hardest part is the first call. After that, it gets easier.

Frequently asked questions

Does my therapist need a PMH-C?
Not strictly. The PMH-C from Postpartum Support International is the clearest sign someone chose to specialize, but a therapist with specific perinatal training, supervision, and a practice that is mostly pregnant and postpartum moms can be just as good. What you are checking for is real training, not a mention of postpartum in a long list.
How is a perinatal therapist different from a regular therapist?
Training and expectations. A perinatal specialist knows intrusive thoughts are common and stays calm about them, factors sleep, feeding, and hormones into the picture, gives you things to try that fit life with a newborn, and knows which prescribers understand pregnancy and breastfeeding. A general therapist may be excellent and still treat postpartum depression like any other depression.
Can I start therapy while pregnant or breastfeeding?
Yes. Therapy is safe at any point, and it is usually the first thing to try. If medication would also help, a specialist will coordinate with a prescriber who understands pregnancy and breastfeeding rather than guessing.
What if there is no perinatal specialist near me?
Look by video. Psychologists with PSYPACT authority can see you in more than forty states, and the evidence for online therapy in postpartum depression and anxiety is good. Start with the Postpartum Support International directory filtered to your state.
How long will I need to see someone?
It varies, but a common shape is weekly sessions for the first eight to twelve weeks, then every other week or monthly as things settle. Most moms I work with feel more like themselves around the third month. If you are not improving after a couple of months, a good therapist changes the approach or helps you find someone else.
Dr. Jana Rundle

Dr. Jana Rundle

Licensed Clinical Psychologist

Ready to Begin Your Healing Journey?

Take the first step with a free 15-minute consultation.

Schedule Your Consultation